A Guide on How to Dispute a Car Accident Fault

Photo of author

By Micheal Reason

Car accidents can be a distressing experience, and determining who is at fault is crucial for insurance claims and legal purposes. However, assigning fault is not always straightforward, and it’s not uncommon for different parties involved to have different accounts of what happened. In such cases, disputing the fault becomes necessary. In this article, we will explore the steps you can take to dispute car accident faults effectively.

Understanding the Importance of Fault Determination

Why is Fault Determination Important?

Before delving into the dispute process, it’s essential to understand why fault determination matters. Fault is directly linked to liability, meaning the person at fault is responsible for covering damages and injuries. Insurance companies rely on fault determination to process claims, and it can significantly impact the compensation you receive.

Factors Affecting Fault Determination

Fault determination relies on various factors, including police reports, eyewitness testimonies, traffic laws, and other pieces of evidence. Insurance adjusters play a crucial role in evaluating these factors and assigning percentages of fault to each party involved.

Step-by-Step Guide to Dispute Car Accident Fault

1. Gather Evidence Immediately

After the accident, ensure you collect as much evidence as possible. Take photographs of the accident scene, vehicle damage, and any visible injuries. Obtain contact information from witnesses and write down their statements. Additionally, get a copy of the police report, as it can provide essential details.

2. Review the Police Report

The police report serves as an official record of the accident. Review it thoroughly to check for inaccuracies or missing information. If you find any discrepancies, notify the police department and request corrections.

3. Consult with Your Insurance Company

Inform your insurance company about the accident and provide them with the evidence you gathered. They will initiate their investigation and may assign an adjuster to assess the fault.

4. Consult with a Personal Injury Attorney

If you believe the fault determination is unfair, consider consulting with a personal injury attorney. They can provide legal advice, evaluate your case, and represent you during the dispute process.

5. Communicate Clearly with the Other Party’s Insurance

Exchange information with the other party’s insurance company, but be cautious about what you say. Avoid admitting fault, as it may harm your case. Stick to factual information and direct all communication through your attorney if you have one.

6. Provide Witness Testimonies

If there were witnesses to the accident, ask them to provide written statements detailing what they saw. Witness testimonies can be valuable in supporting your version of events.

7. Obtain Expert Opinions

Depending on the complexity of the case, seeking expert opinions may strengthen your dispute. Accident reconstruction experts, medical professionals, or engineers can provide objective analyses that support your claim.

8. Be Patient and Persistent

Disputing car accident fault can be a lengthy process, so be patient. Stay persistent and follow up with the involved parties regularly to ensure your case doesn’t get overlooked.

9. Mediation and Arbitration

In some cases, mediation or arbitration may be required to resolve the dispute. These methods involve a neutral third party who helps both parties reach a fair settlement.

10. File a Lawsuit

If all else fails, you may need to file a lawsuit to have the fault determination reviewed by a court. This is a last resort, as lawsuits can be time-consuming and expensive.



Disputing car accident fault requires a systematic approach and thorough gathering of evidence. Remember to remain calm, communicate effectively, and seek legal advice if necessary. Ultimately, a fair fault determination ensures you receive the compensation you rightfully deserve.


Is it always necessary to dispute car accident faults?

Not always. If the fault determination seems reasonable and fair, disputing may not be necessary.

Can I dispute the fault without involving my insurance company?

Yes, you can, but involving your insurance company can provide additional support and guidance.

What if the other party involved is not cooperating?

If the other party is uncooperative, your attorney can help navigate the situation and gather evidence.

Will the disputing fault affect my insurance premium?

It might. If the fault determination changes in your favor, your premium may not be impacted.

How long does the dispute process usually take?

The length of the dispute process varies depending on the complexity of the case and the cooperation of all parties involved.

Leave a Comment